Because of some not-so-interesting technical reasons I ended up on the mailing list for reporting bugs in Wikipedia’s mobile app (please see disclaimer in the end).
Reading real Wikipedia readers’ reactions is fascinating.
A lot of the emails there are just empty. People just press the button to report a problem and don’t actually write anything at all.
Sometimes they are just slightly less than empty. For example, quite a lot of people write things like “When will you fix your stupid app already???!?!!”. This may seem pointless and unconstructive, but actually these people think that there is context to what they say, because they see complaints from other people at Google’s or Apple’s app store and they assume that the app’s maintainers are aware of them. Some people also threaten to give the app a low rating in the app store; it’s not really wrong, but it’s not very helpful either.
A lot of the emails are about connectivity problems in Android 2.2.2 and about screen rotation problems on iPad. The developers are aware of both issues and are working on them.
And a whole lot of reports suggest fixes in content, rather than technical problems. Some of them are pointless, for example “The facts on this web sight is wrong and i want it changed to the corrected statement”. It never occurred to that person that it would be helpful to say what information is wrong or what should be written there (it can also be a troll). And some people do make useful suggestions. For example, one person reported that Obama didn’t write “How the Grinch Stole Christmas“. The report was correct: somebody indeed vandalized the article about the children’s book and wrote that its author is Obama. It was an easy fix, so I just fixed it myself and replied, thanking the person for the report and saying that in the future she can fix it herself by pressing the “edit” button.
If I see that fixing the problem will take more than a minute, I just reply with “you can fix it yourself”. This does make me think that a more robust way of telling people that they can fix the problems themselves is needed.
All these issues aside, there is something truly wonderful about this app: People write these emails in their language without caring at all about who will read them. Reporting a bug in Bugzilla is hard for many reasons, one of which is certainly the language. But the app gives the user a completely localized experience, so the users don’t think twice before sending a bug report in their language.
And this is a good thing. Some People from Some Companies told me explicitly that they give up on processing reports from too many people in too many languages; not Wikimedia. Wikimedia may acknowledge that it’s hard, Wikimedia won’t commit to replying to each email, but Wikimedia wouldn’t just shut it down and ignore it completely, either. We would rather think about more efficient ways to get volunteers to reply to people efficiently or to help people fix the issues themselves – that’s what the whole “wiki” idea is about in the first place.
(Important disclaimer: I am involved with this mailing list as a volunteer. It has nothing to do with the paid work that I do for the Wikimedia Foundation. I do not officially represent the Foundation in any actions that I take with regard to that mailing list.)